The end times will continue (until morale improves)

Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor on the fight for the paradise that’s already here.
Emily Pothast
The end times will continue (until morale improves)

Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor are done arguing over whether the odious amalgam of religious apocalypticism, ethnonationalism, and tech accelerationism which has embedded itself in the structures of contemporary life can be properly termed fascist. 

In the introduction to their new book, End Times Fascism and the Fight for the Living World, they write: 

While it was once controversial to point out the parallels between today’s hard-right governments and the openly fascist regimes that attempted to cleanse Europe of its designated out-groups last century, today the continuities have become impossible to ignore. That this is fascism, at least in its early stages, is now taken for granted by many scholars of authoritarianism. 

These unnamed “many scholars” could include former Yale professors Jason Stanley and Timothy Snyder, who have both recently decamped (not coincidentally) to Canada. Of course, Klein and Taylor’s decision to use the word “fascism” was met with resistance. David Marchese spent most of his New York Times interview asking if talking like this was going to alienate those who need convincing. Piers Morgan, who didn’t read the book, repeatedly interrupted Klein during their interview to tell her he thinks “woke” leftists are the real fascists. Such reactions are instructive. Like the rows of feathers that forestall the dampening of a duck’s backside, this fixation on terminology staves off deeper engagement with a text that describes fascism not as an anomaly of the twentieth century, but as “capitalism with bared teeth.” 

We should not expect the fascism of the twenty-first century to be identical to that of the twentieth century, the authors argue. Conditions are different, starting with climate change and humanity’s expanded capacity for destruction. Klein and Taylor draw on Robert Paxton, Umberto Eco, and W.E.B. DuBois, among others, to stress underlying continuities between past and present movements that “tap into popular passions and resentments” while “equating elite experiences of injury and lost status with the more widespread pain of working people.” Unlike the horizontal solidarities of worker-led revolutions, fascism appeals to working-class anxieties in order to vertically align working people (at the expense of dehumanized out-groups) with the corporate class’s political will to capture state power. To enforce itself, it adapts and redeploys the brutal methods already used on colonized and enslaved people on new populations at home.

According to the authors, what makes today’s fascism distinctive is its awareness that the world as we know it is “coming to an imminent end.” It therefore has nothing positive to offer beyond the fantasy of bunkered survival for a select few. End times fascists will not promise to make the trains run on time because they do not believe in the continued survival of a mass polity (and if they did, they would make them take Waymos). 

This grim and joyless nihilism, ironically, gives Klein and Taylor cause for hope. Autocrats can only pose as populists if they are popular. But what if most people actually don’t want to bomb Iran or live within humming distance of a data center? What if most of us don’t want to watch our neighbors get abducted or see the whole of human creativity replaced with AI slop? Through interviews with grassroots organizers, Klein and Taylor frame popular discontent as a political resource, which appears to have been borne out in a record number of progressive candidates winning in the 2026 US midterms. They point to Joyce Carol Oates’s legendary takedown of Elon Musk on X as emblematic of the widening chasm between oligarchs and everyone else. Unlike Musk, who shows no evidence that he actually enjoys anything, most people do enjoy things, and would like to continue to do so on a planet that is not a self-incinerating cyberhell. 

The near-universal capacity for human enjoyment creates an opening for activism. During their conversation with Poulomi Saha at City Arts and Lectures in San Francisco, Klein and Taylor spent a bit of time teasing out what they call the book’s “witchier” themes, drawing a contrast between a bunkered worldview that seeks to “alienate us from embodied reality” and the possibility of wonder, even reverence toward the “living world.” To illustrate the latter, they draw on the Yiddish concept of “hereness” (doikayt) as set forth in Molly Crabapple’s recent history of the Jewish Labor Bund. Paradise, in their telling, is neither in heaven nor on Mars, nor will it be found in the resort city that Trump’s Board of Peace vows to build on Gaza’s ashes. It is not a transcendent reality nor a deferred future state.  Paradise is a dimension of our present reality, threaded through the ecosystems of the only known planet capable of sustaining life. Here, the authors note parallels with other world-affirming, relational cosmologies that demand ongoing acts of reparation and care.

Though they don’t overtly describe it this way, End Times Fascism is a work of pantheistic political theology (or counter-theology, if you prefer), asserting the intrinsic value of the natural world over and against the deification of greed. Its breezy, journalistic style helps conceptualize multiple trends as interrelated facets of the same big, godawful shape. Even more importantly, it offers an earnestly hopeful countervibe by refusing to concede that the oligarchs’ desired outcomes are inevitable.

This hopeful tone is sustained by interviews with activists who provide models for nonviolent direct action. These include organizers in Memphis, Tennessee, where Elon Musk is building a massively polluting supercomputer; in Venice, Italy, where protesters successfully derailed Jeff Bezos’s wedding; in Minnesota, where religious institutions and regular people banded together to protect immigrants during Operation Metro Surge, and on Zohran Mamdani’s successful mayoral campaign in New York City, which they call the “antithesis of fascism” in its inclusive solidarity. 

Although End Times Fascism draws on themes Klein and Taylor have been thinking about for decades, it was written under somewhat hasty conditions—inspired by the beginning of the second Trump presidency and released in time to spark conversations before the midterms. The timing was a wise decision, and the argument is strong, but I do have a few friendly notes on the execution. Complex concepts like “messianism,” “eschatology,” and “apocalypse” are frequently invoked but left undefined, assuming audience familiarity but leaving interpretive space where clarity would be helpful. For example, the authors describe “the Antichrist” as a “biblical figure,” sidestepping how much this idea—which doesn’t actually appear in the Bible as a cohesive entity—is itself a composite phantom of interpretation, most recently by Peter Thiel. 

Luckily, other books exist and we can read them too. In The Nerd Reich: Silicon Valley Fascism and the War on Democracy, West Bay journalist Gil Durán has done a comparatively painstaking job of defining and historicizing key religious terms, resulting in a more incisive picture of the technocratic aspirations (and thus existential stakes) of the so-called Dark Enlightenment. Durán also provides background on the emergence of the antidemocratic worldviews of guys like Curtis Yarvin, Peter Thiel, and Marc Andreessen, which helps make their underlying motivations and shadowy influence on our current government easier to see. Understanding these dynamics is particularly relevant in our own strange little corner of the country. While last week’s midterms saw big wins for progressives nationwide, California voters catastrophically failed to pass a one-time tax on billionaires and the interests of the Bay Area tech elite became even more entrenched. Clearly there are some lessons here that we have yet to internalize.

Klein and Taylor’s analysis of Silicon Valley may be limited, but they have a larger picture in view, identifying religious fundamentalists, tech accelerationists, and ethnonationalists as three factions which have found common cause in the “emerging, fractious, and often contradictory movement” they call end times fascism. This framing helps reveal the fault lines in the coalition, even if it misses many of the continuities which have been established by scholars of religion. Yii-Jan Lin’s 2024 Immigration and Apocalypse: How the Book of Revelation Shaped American Immigration, for example, examines the use of apocalyptic religion to justify a walled-city approach to border policy. Mary-Jane Rubenstein’s 2022 Astrotopia: The Dangerous Religion of the Corporate Space Race prefigures several of the points Klein and Taylor make about end times escapism. The authors’ focus on “embodied reality” also echoes a broader turn toward embodiment in religious studies and the humanities. 

Donald H. Akenson’s trilogy on the history of apocalyptic evangelical Christianity (2016-2023), meanwhile, provides indispensable background on the colonial origins of contemporary end-times prophecy. Among other things, Akenson details the conferences held at the Powerscourt Estate in County Wicklow, Ireland in the 1820s and 30s, where the theology that would come to be known as dispensationalism was worked out by aristocrats hoping to stave off a peasant uprising resembling the French Revolution. The Powerscourt Estate made headlines in the summer of 2026 when an exclusive retreat that Peter Thiel had planned to host on its premises was cancelled amidst rumors of protests, though the historical significance of the location was lost on most commentators. 

Klein and Taylor’s musings on the “novel symbiosis” of “Big Tech and Big Oil” also bypass the oil industry’s formative and ongoing role in the funding and development of evangelical end-times Christianity. This tendency is exemplified in the publication of The Fundamentals: A Testimony To the Truth (1910-1915) by Union Oil founder Lyman Stewart, who converted to Christianity during the so-called Businessmen’s Revival of the late 1850s and proceeded to charter a version of Christianity amenable to his own extractive interests. Any attempt to create a theology around what is currently going on between Silicon Valley and Washington, D.C. must be read through the lens of the bespoke apocalyptic theologies of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries that have been instrumental in driving us (pun sadly intended) to our present coordinates on the Doomsday Clock. 

Put simply, the factions that Klein and Taylor identify are even more closely imbricated than the text acknowledges, and have been for a long time. But End Times Fascism does not present itself as a work of history. It is an exhortation for our present moment, and this is where it shines. When the authors do reach for the past, it is not to exhaustively catalog its contents, but to uncover, with the spirit of Walter Benjamin, how “past agonies can become fuel for victories in the present.” They also want to invoke and sustain wonder—our capacity to gaze into the night sky without the desire to fill that “inky unknown” with tons of “space junk”—unlike those they call “traitors to creation.” They write:

Most people have the capacity for awe, to gasp at the jeweled beauty of a songbird or the otherworldliness of a whale’s exhalation, or the intricate latticework of an ancient holy site. [...] The fact that this capacity seems to be missing from the men who hold our collective fate in their hands is a personal loss for them—and an existential crisis for the rest of us. 

The conviction that we still have a shot at wresting some semblance of a future from the unimaginative edgelords holding it hostage is a political resource worth fostering. And while the US midterm elections may have signaled the efficacy of this approach, there is clearly much to do, especially here at home. Let us go forth and have a little joy in doing it.

\O/

End Times Fascism And the Fight for the Living World
Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor
FSG; 384 pp; September 2026